Esthetic characteristics of disease (linguistic concept analysis).

L. V. Tuleninova

Abstract


The adequacy of referring disease to the esthetic category of «ugly» on the basis of the analysis of verbal means of representation of the concept in English and in Russian is regarded in the article. The author examines some verbal means of realization of the category of aesthetic evaluation of disease in English and Russian linguistic cultures, in order to see if disease can be referred to the aesthetic category of «ugliness».  The study based on the analysis of various sources reveals elusiveness of the concept disease in the linguistic conciseness of the members of both cultures. The author makes an attempt to find a basis for a more unambiguous reference of illness to evil (which can be traced in the etymology of words, nominating disease in both languages). This causes necessity to reveal value characteristics by determining the aesthetic appreciation of this phenomenon in the society. For this, more than 1.000 language units in each language have been analyzed by the author. The study shows that blurred boundaries between aesthetic appreciation of «beautiful» and «ugly» with regard to disease do not allow to refer disease exclusively to the aesthetic category of «ugliness».  More accurate answers in further studies with new factual material are expected.


Keywords


concept; esthetic category; esthetic estimation; elusiveness; denotation

References


Arskaja M.A. Semanticheskaja kategorija esteticheskoj ocenki (prekrasnoe/bezobraznoe) i ee ontologija v sovremennom nemeckom jazyke : dis. ... kand. filol. nauk [Semantic category of aesthetic evaluation (beautiful / ugly) and its ontology in modern German language. Cand. Diss.]. Irkutsk, 2002. – 185 p.

Devkin V.D. Psevdojekspressija [Pseudo-expression] Obshhie i chastnye problemy funkcional'nyh stilej [General and particular problems of functional styles]. M., Nauka Publ, 1986. – 216 p.

Karaulov Ju.N., Cherkasova G.A., Ufimceva N.F., Sorokin Ju.A., Tarasov E.F. Russkij associativnyj slovar' [Russian associative dictionary] (In 2 vol. Vol. I : Ot stimula k reakcii [From stimulus to reaction], about 7000 stimuli). Moscow, OOO “Astrel” Publ. : OOO “AST” Publ., 2002. Vol.1. – 784 p.

Korolev K. Mifologija Britanskih ostrovov [Mythology of British Isles] (Encyclopedia). Moscow, EKSMO Publ.; Saint Petersburg, Terra Fantastica Publ., 2004. – 640 p.

Levkievskaja E. E. Mify russkogo naroda [Myths of Russian people]. Moscow, OOO “Astrel” Publ.; OOO “AST” Publ.; OAO “Lux” Publ., 2005. – 366 p.

Malinovich Ju.M. Jekspressija i smysl predlozhenija : Problemy jemocional'no-jekspressivnogo sintaksisa [Expression and sense of the sentence : problems of emotional and expressive syntax]. Irkutsk, Irkutsk university publ., 1989. – 216 p.

Markelova T.V. Semantika i pragmatika vyrazhenija ocenki v russkom jazyke [Semantics and pragmatics of the expression of evaluation in Russian]. Filol. nauki.Phylol. sciences, 1995, no.3. – pp. 67-79.

Pisanova T.V. Nacional'no-kul'turnye aspekty ocenochnoj semantiki : Jesteticheskie i jeticheskie ocenki [National cultural aspects of evaluative semantics : esthetic and ethical evaluations]. M., IKAR, Publ., 1997. – 320 p.

Chernejko L.O. Porozhdenie i vosprijatie mezhlichnostnyh ocenok [Generation and perception of interpersonal evaluations]. Filol. nauki.– Phylol. sciences, 1996, no. 6. – pp. 42 – 53.

Boyd Kenneth M. Disease, illness, sickness, health, healing and wholeness: exploring some elusive concepts. Journal of Medical Ethics, 2000, no. 26. – pp. 9 – 17. Available at: http://mh.bmjjournals.com/cgi/content/full/28/1/#ABS.

Hartman Jan. Illness as evil and Illness as good. Bioethics, 2002. Available at: http://www.iphils.uj.edu.pl/~j.hartman/do.php?c=bioethics&p=illness_as_evil_and_illness_as_good

Kiss, G.R., Armstrong C., Milroy R., Piper J. An associative thesaurus of English and its computer analysis. The Computer and Literary Studies, Edinburgh, University Press, 1973. Available at: http://www.eat.rl.ac.uk/cgi-bin/eat-server.


GOST Style Citations


  1. Арская М.А. Семантическая категория эстетической оценки (прекрасное/безобразное) и ее онтология в современном немецком языке : дис. ... канд. филол. наук : 10.02.04 / Марина Александровна Арская. –  Иркутск, 2002. – 185 с.
  2. Девкин В.Д. Псевдоэкспрессия / В. Д. Девкин. // Общие и частные проблемы функциональных стилей. – М. : Наука, 1986. – 216 с.
  3. Караулов Ю.Н. Русский ассоциативный словарь. В 2 т. Т. I. От стимула к реакции : около 7000 стимулов / Ю.Н. Караулов, Г.А. Черкасова, Н.Ф. Уфимцева, Ю.А. Сорокин, Е.Ф. Тарасов. – М. : ООО «Издательство Астрель» : ООО «Издательство АСТ», 2002. Т.1. –784 с. Т.2. – 992с. 
  4. Королев К. Мифология Британских островов : энциклопедия / сост., общ. ред. К. Королева. – М. : ЭКСМО; СПб. : Terra Fantastica, 2004. – 640 с.
  5. Левкиевская Е.Е.  Мифы русского народа / Е.Е. Левкиевская. –  М.: ООО «Издательство Астрель» : ООО «Издательство АСТ» : ОАО «Люкс», 2005. – 366 с.
  6. Малинович Ю.М. Экспрессия и смысл предложения : Проблемы эмоционально-экспрессивного синтаксиса / Ю.М. Малинович. – Иркутск : Изд-во Иркутский ун-т, 1989. – 216 с.
  7. Маркелова Т.В. Семантика и прагматика выражения оценки в русском языке / Т. В. Маркелова // Филол. науки. – 1995. – №3. – С. 67-79.
  8. Писанова Т.В. Национально-культурные аспекты оценочной семантики: Эстетические и этические оценки / Т.В. Писанова. – М. : Издательство ИКАР, 1997. – 320 с.
  9. 9.      Чернейко Л.О. Порождение и восприятие межличностных оценок / Л.О. Чернейко // Филологические науки. – 1996. – №. 6. – C. 42 – 53.
  10. Boyd Kenneth M. Disease, illness, sickness, health, healing and wholeness: exploring  some  elusive  concepts  [Electronic resource] / Kenneth M. Boyd // Journal of Medical Ethics. – 2000. –  № 26. – P. 9 – 17 // Available at: http://mh.bmjjournals.com/cgi/content/full/28/1/#ABS. 
  11. Hartman Jan. Illness as evil and Illness as good [Electronic resource] / Jan Hartman // Вioethics. – 2002. // Available at: http://www.iphils.uj.edu.pl/~j.hartman/do.php?c=bioethics&p=illness_as_evil_and_illness_as_good.
  12. Kiss, G.R. An associative thesaurus of English and its computer analysis [Electronic resource] / G.R. Kiss, C. Armstrong, R. Milroy, J. Piper. – In Aitken, A.J., Bailey, R.W. and Hamilton-Smith, N. (Eds.), The Computer and Literary Studies. – Edinburgh: University Press. 1973. // Available at: http://www.eat.rl.ac.uk/cgi-bin/eat-server.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2015 Journal of the National Technical University of Ukraine “KPI”: Philology and Educational Studies

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

ISSN 2410-8278 (Online), ISSN 2307-1591 (Print)